The NEJM Challenge: Reassessing Race in Clinical Algorithms
Episode Description
Many of the clinical algorithms clinicians use every day include race as a variable, often because it showed up as statistically significant in an older dataset rather than for a sound biological reason, which may have unintended consequences in patient care. In this episode, host Dr. Shazia Siddique talks with Dr. Helen Burstin, CEO of the Council of Medical Specialty Societies (CMSS), and Dr. Mary Beth Hamel, Executive Editor of the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM), about the NEJM Challenge, a new contest that asks researchers to reassess the role of race in algorithms.
The Challenge is part of ENGAGE, a national initiative coordinated by CMSS and funded by the Doris Duke Foundation, with MDCalc, NEJM, and the Association for Clinical and Translational Science as partners. Burstin and Hamel discuss what the field learned from revising the eGFR equation, how researchers' handling of race in submitted papers has changed, and why simply removing race is not always the answer.
They also walk through how the Challenge works. Round 1 asks for a three-page proposal that identifies an algorithm still in clinical use and makes the case for revising it. Twenty Round 1 winners receive $1,250 each and advance to Round 2, where they get mentorship and technical support as they develop their methods and a feasibility plan. Up to five final winners receive $20,000 each. Round 1 entries are due March 29, 2027.
What You'll Learn
• Why race ended up in so many clinical algorithms, and what it often stands in for
• How ENGAGE brings specialty societies, journals, statisticians, and MDCalc together on this problem
• How the two-round NEJM Challenge works, including prizes, timeline, and support for finalists
• What makes a strong entry: patient impact, the right mix of clinical and methods expertise, and a realistic plan for data
Links
• NEJM Challenge: nejm.org/nejm-challenge
• ENGAGE and MDCalc's statement on race in medical calculators: mdcalc.com/race
• Council of Medical Specialty Societies: cmss.org
• NEJM roundtable, "The Use of Race in Clinical Guidance and Decision Making"
• NEJM Intention to Treat podcast series, "The Race Equation"
• MDCalc: mdcalc.com



























