DOCSF 2026: Panel - Evaluating Innovation: Publication and Grant Review in the Era of AI and Rapid Technological Change
Episode Description
Recorded live at DOCSF Science 2026 in San Francisco, this panel asks what good AI science looks like, and who should be accountable for it when authors, reviewers, and editors all use AI. The answer the panel keeps coming back to: AI assists; a human decides.
Our panelists:
- Christian Pean, MD, MS, orthopaedic trauma surgeon and executive director of AI and IT innovation, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Duke University
- Thomas Peterson, PhD, assistant professor of orthopaedic surgery, UCSF
- Christina Nelson, director of publishing and editorial operations, JBJS
- Lee Grossman, CEO, Orthopaedic Research and Education Foundation (OREF)
The discussion moves from benchmarks versus real-world data to the practical side of publishing. JBJS has just updated its AI guidelines, and Nelson explains why disclosure matters more than limits on AI use. Dr. Strelzow describes a submission where 18 of 20 references did not exist. Grossman explains why OREF has no plans to restrict AI the way NIH has, and asks the audience how to fund AI science the field does not yet know how to review.
The room pushes back too: on whether the research paper format will survive, on reproducibility when orthopaedic journals do not require authors to submit their models, and on what the penalty for fabricated references should be.



























