Your Patient Trusts ChatGPT More Than You Now: The New Yorker's Dr. Dhruv Khullar on Medical Authority in the Age of AI
Episode Description
Dhruv Khullar is a hospitalist at New York Presbyterian, a health policy researcher at Weill Cornell, and a contributing writer to The New Yorker. That combination is rarer than it should be. Most physicians writing about medicine observe it from a remove. Dhruv rounds on patients in the morning, then sits down to report on what medicine is becoming for one of the most widely read publications in the country. What he writes carries clinical weight because he was just in the room.
Over the past several years, Dhruv has reported at length on AI and its risks for clinical training, the structural forces reshaping the profession, and what he calls the Gilded Age of American medicine: dazzling innovation on the surface, structural rot underneath. That rot has a specific anatomy. Private equity now owns roughly 500 hospitals in the United States, and in some markets a single firm controls more than half of physician practices in a given specialty. Medicare Advantage insurers have turned risk-adjusted payment into a revenue strategy, systematically capturing diagnostic codes for conditions patients may not know they have and that no physician is treating, because sicker-looking patients generate more money. The value-based care revolution that many physicians believed in, Dhruv included, has not delivered on its promise. And all of it is happening while AI is simultaneously raising the ceiling of what medicine can do and quietly lowering the floor of what training physicians are being asked to do themselves.
In this episode of How I Doctor, Graham sits down with Dhruv to get into what his reporting has actually uncovered and what it means for physicians living inside this moment. They talk about the difference between cognitive deskilling and cognitive foreclosure: the risk that medical trainees who turn to AI before doing the hard thinking themselves may never build the reasoning infrastructure that clinical judgment depends on. Dhruv describes watching an AI model called Cabot go head to head with one of the best diagnosticians he has ever trained alongside on a New England Journal CPC case, and nearly gasping when the machine finished in minutes. They also get into what happens to medical authority when a patient in your ER trusts ChatGPT over the physician standing in front of them, how Medicare Advantage is being gamed, and whether medicine can still be a calling after the system has spent years making it feel like a job.
What You'll Learn in This Episode:
- Why cognitive foreclosure may be a bigger threat to physician training than cognitive deskilling
- What Dhruv witnessed when an AI went up against one of the best diagnosticians he has ever trained alongside, on one of medicine's hardest diagnostic case formats, and why it made him nearly gasp
- How Medicare Advantage insurers have turned risk adjustment into a revenue strategy
- Why the most successful version of physician advocacy will be built around patient needs rather than professional status
- Whether medicine can still be a calling after the system has spent years turning it into a job
🩺 Offcall is more than a platform — it’s a community. Join today!
📝 For a full transcript of this episode click HERE
🎧 Subscribe to receive new How I Doctor episodes directly in your feed here: https://episodes.fm/1767429315
👨⚕️Follow Dr. Graham Walker on
LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/in/graham-walker-md/
IG https://www.instagram.com/ubergraham/
Bluesky https://bsky.app/profile/drgrahamwalker.com
✉️ Join our newsletter On/Offcall here https://offcall.beehiiv.com/subscribe
🟧 Follow Offcall on
LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/company/joinoffcall/
Listen On
